Yes, the Holiday post is reserved for watchers of the journal

That was kind of my point, actually -- I am watching the comm, but because I (and none of the other watchers, from what I can tell on the profile) are not members of the comm, we can't see a locked entry.

you should definitely check out my Holiday Wishlist Post.

I will, althought I'm terrible at participating. I'll do my best, however. :)